Showing posts with label ning. Show all posts
Showing posts with label ning. Show all posts

Monday, April 19, 2010

New Additions to the Digital Backpack - Social Network Platform Special Edition @courosa #edtech #edchat

A disproportionately high percentage of the edtech community has for the past few years used Ning as the platform of choice for creating and growing education-related social networks. Many of us have come to rely on Ning for it's ease of use and how accessible it has been. One of the biggest reasons so many of us flocked to Ning was it's cost. Ning offered a nice free option for small networks not needing the advanced resources and support that many larger commercial networks need. Last week Ning announced a new company strategy whereby they will be phasing out free accounts within the next 30 days.

This obviously causes a dilemma for many of us who have built networks on this platform. While it would be good practice to support a tool we like by paying for it I fear that the pricing options will be too high for many many valuable networks created for non-profit organizations and many networks created for personal learning. Essentially, the problem posed by asking free users to pay for premium service is those who have networks of under 100 members will be charged roughly the same as those who have tens of thousands of members. Therefore, it will be necessary for many of us to bail on Ning and find other options.

While I agree with Alec Courosa that for long-term sustainability networks need to be self-hosted (and there are a lot of great open source options for this out there) for those educators who do not have access to a server or who do not need their networks to exist forever self-hosting is not a viable option either.

Luckily, there are a plethora of options available for network creators who don't have the option to self-host or funds for premium services. Many of these options are openly courting our education community and nearly all of them have been working to find ways to make the transition from Ning as easy as possible. So, the following are new additions to the Digital Backpack that support free hosted social networks for educators:

  • - Create your own social educational network. (offers 10gb free storage, forums, group pages, integration with Google Gadgets, Wiki, file sharing, and RSS) Students under 13 must have parent permission to use this tool.
  • - Create your own social educational network. (offers 1gb free storage for photos, group pages, forums, and RSS)
  • - Create your own social educational network. (offers forums, group pages, Wiki, file sharing, and RSS) Students under 13 must have parent permission to use this tool.
  • - Create your own social educational network. (only offers 100mb free storage, supports group pages, & forums with threaded discussions and very robust WYSIWYG editor for posts) Students under 13 must have parent permission to use this tool.


Consequently, I have a handful of Ning networks I have created and maintain. I do not have any funds to buy their premium services. Therefore, in the next few weeks I will be migrating these networks to other services. Most of them will become Grou.ps networks since that platform offers the most short-term promise. (They also offer this handy Ning migration tool: http://grou.ps/ning.php) If you are a member of any of my networks (iTeach Mobile, Minnesota Educator PD Commons, or Crosswinds Teacher Network) you will be notified shortly about this move. With any luck you will hardly notice the transition.

Friday, April 16, 2010

Social Network Platform Comparison

Click Here to see the original Google Docs File


File Sharing
Storage Space
Forums
Groups
Calendar/
Events
RSS
Other notable features
CIPA
Downsides
Bigtent
yes
unknown
yes
yes
yes
unknown
Facebook Integration

Has a built-in money collection tool for group events and fund raisers.

Has a built-in polling feature.
13
URL is not customizable
Grouply
no
100mb
no

Grouply has a message board feature but it does not offer threaded discussions. Each post is independent.
no
yes
yes
Looks a lot like Ning
Admin determines when they setup the group
free version gives very little storage

Does not support threaded discussions

Does not support Groups or file sharing.
Mixxt
yes, but as it's own category. Can't attach files to forum posts
unknown
yes
yes
yes
yes
Highly customizable.

Simple interface.

Has wiki feature
12
Templates are not as visually appealing as other networks.
Grou.ps
yes, but as it's own category. Can't attach files to forum posts
10GB
yes
yes
yes
yes
Highly customizable.

Many template choices.

Easy to use interface.

Looks and feels a lot like Ning.

Has many features that Ning doesn't even offer such as a site search engine, map modules, wiki pages, a file download module, and games.

Integrates with Google Gadgets.

IDK
still in beta, who knows if it will remain free, could suffer the same fate as Ning
WackWall
no
unknown
yes
no
yes
no
Simple interface
IDK
very limiting

no layout or feature customization for admin



Conclusion:

Grou.ps hands down wins this battle and is a serious contender that could rival Ning even if Ning kept it's free accounts.